Plastic Surgery and Aesthetic Medicine, ISSN NoIssnPrint print, 0000-0000 online, Open Access
Article copyright, the authors; Journal compilation copyright, Plast Surg Aesthet Med and Elmer Press Inc
Journal website https://psam.elmerpub.com

Original Article

Volume 1, 2026, e3


Inter- and Intra-Rater Reliability of Physician Assessments of Artificial Intelligence-Generated Female Gluteal Esthetic Images

Figures

↓  Figure 1. Three examples of the images created with genAI: (a) posterior view, (b) 45° view, (c) side view. GenAI: generative artificial intelligence.
Figure 1.
↓  Figure 2. (a) William Hogarth’s illustration of the line of beauty curve 4 compared to other lines (ResearchGate—uploaded by George Mathias Kondolf); (b) Two symmetric 4 curves superimposed on a rear view; (c) The 4-curve superimposed on a 45° projection.
Figure 2.
↓  Figure 3. Example of the ovoid inclined forward at 60°.
Figure 3.

Tables

↓  Table 1. Reliability and Internal Consistency
 
StatisticValue
ICC: intraclass correlation coefficient; α: alpha.
ICC (2, 16) mean of 16 raters0.586–0.805
Cronbach’s α (B1–B7)0.951 (n = 1,053)

 

↓  Table 2. C1: Ideal Female Butt Classification
 
ResponseCountPercentage95% CI
CI: confidence interval.
Y (yes)69365.662.7–68.4
B (borderline)15915.113.0–17.3
N (no)20419.317.0–21.8

 

↓  Table 3. Intra-Rater Consistency
 
MetricValue
ICC: intraclass correlation coefficient.
Mean absolute difference0.46
Exact agreement60.6%
Agreement within ±1 point93.6%
Test–retest ICC (3, 1)≈0.46–0.57

 

↓  Table 4. Pooled Scores (Mean ± SD)
 
ParameterMean ± SD
SD: standard deviation.
A (overall esthetic)6.11 ± 1.00
B1 (proportion and harmony)6.22 ± 1.00
B2 (upper pole fullness)6.13 ± 0.98
B3 (lateral hip contour)6.09 ± 1.01
B4 (projection)6.19 ± 0.96
B5 (infragluteal fold)6.11 ± 1.00
B6 (symmetry)6.34 ± 0.94
B7 (anatomical plausibility—naturalness)6.30 ± 1.00

 

↓  Table 5. Quality Control Flags
 
CategoryCountPercentage95% CI
CI: confidence interval; AI: artificial intelligence.
D1—AI/visual artifacts affecting contour
  N (none)96291.1089.23–92.67
  Mi (mild)524.923.77–6.40
  Mo (moderate)393.692.71–5.01
  S (severe)30.280.10–0.83
D2—Pose/camera non-standardization
  N (no issue)97191.9590.15–93.44
  P (pose)807.586.13–9.33
  C (camera)20.190.05–0.69
  B (both)30.280.10–0.83